Wow, that is crazy Tam! Reminds me of this cat we had that would steal the miniature Reese's cups I put out at Christmas, eat the peanut butter center, and then wrap the chocolate back up so you couldn't tell. It took a while to figure out it was the cat doing it! To this day, I have not figured out how he did it.

Anyway, I digress....I would take the DVDs back. I bet there are more on the shelves like LJ said and probably more complaints. How annoying!
That must be the smartest cat in the world lol